Quick Slants from the 2009 NFL Week Four, Where Private Eyes Are Watching Mendenhall
October 9, 2009
- There is no player in football I will be watching more closely than Rashard Mendenhall this week, and I’m sure I’m not alone. I mean, I was paying attention, and I had never seen him perform well at the NFL level. I don’t watch much college football, but I knew there was a reason the Steelers drafted the young man in the first round a summer ago, they’re pretty good at talent evaluation, I just didn’t know what it was. Then came Sunday Night Football and the man was a fucking beast. Mendenhall ran extremely hard, followed his blocks and made decisive cuts, and then got the yards on the field with power and authority. And that’s all the Steelers, and fantasy owners, want from the kid. He’s not Chris Johnson or Adrian Peterson, we know that, but if he can just grind out the yards given he’ll be extremely valuable. I firmly believe Willie Parker is done.
Attitude and preparation are certainly questions though, which is why I’m so curious to see if Mendenhall can step on the throats of the woebegone Detroit Lions defense. 85 yards and a TD won’t cut it this week. I need to see more. If I don’t, I’m selling high.
Rashard Mendenhall photo credit: Icon SMI
- The Cowboys backfield has the potential to be a high-profit unit in fantasy, but it’s a confusing mess right now. Felix Jones can’t stay on the field, Marion Barber doesn’t look right and his bruising style will always lend itself to further injury. It’s not hard to imagine Tashard Choice, the least heralded and lowest drafted of the three but the guy who has looked solid whenever called upon, emerging as the most valuable commodity there. I wouldn’t mind owning him in any league.
- As long as a healthy Carson Palmer was under center and Cedric Benson was toting the rock I never thought I would say this, but the Bengals are a better running team than a passing team right now. The offensive line hasn’t been giving Carson Palmer much time in the pocket and he’s looked skittish and unsure. Palmer can still make the throws when called upon, but the improved defense and rushing attack has meant that’s happened less than at any point in Palmer’s career. I still believe in his talent, and he has weapons outside, but as it stands Palmer is strictly a mid-tier fantasy starter going forward.
- Brett Favre was the story of the week, and with good reason. That was an electric game for the Vikings from start to finish and No. 4 performed better than anybody could have predicted. He looked sharp, under control and more in-sync with his wideouts. I have a minor bone to pick though. Brett still has the zip on every pass that travels less than 20 or 25 yards, and he can fit it in with the best of them. Outside that range, though, he struggles. It was a concern I expressed last week in this space, and Monday didn’t change my mind: he doesn’t throw a true deep ball. Favre throws rainbows, overcompensates with his delivery and keeps it either too tight on the sideline or out of bounds because he doesn’t trust it.
It’s something the Vikings can work with, but it’s a limitation that defenses can take advantage of, too. And it’s a shame, because few teams have two playmakers like Bernard Berrian and Percy Harvin that can get deep in a hurry. Another takeaway, and something we’ve been talking about a lot here, is what an attractive target Sidney Rice is. Injury ruined his 2008 season, but he looks fluid again. Rice isn’t a burner, but he’s sure-handed, big and makes plays in the air. Favre looks totally comfortable throwing to him now. That makes eight Vikings (including DEF) worth owning in fantasy. As a Viqueens fan, that’s fun.
10 more nuggets of essential football wisdom, after the jump …
No CommentsPosted by Andrew Thell on Oct. 9, 2009 at 3:03am in NFL, NFL Fantasy News

You’ll notice three somewhat fantasy-relevant names missing from this week’s running back ranks: Laurence Maroney, Sammy Morris, and Fred Taylor. They all play for the New England Patriots, and until further notice we can’t necessarily advocate starting any of them. Some backfield platoons can be dealt with, but this is one you shouldn’t want any part of.
No bye-week blues as far as tight ends go this year. With Antonio Gates, Jermichael Finley, Jeremy Shockey, and Greg Olsen all getting the week off, there should be an abundance of free-agent possibilities ready and waiting on your league’s waiver wire.
Brett Favre was on fire Monday night against the Green Bay Packers, but Jared Allen was every bit his equal on the other side of the ball.
The fantasy scramble known as byes kicked in last week, but Week 5 is the first time this season where a number of owners are desperately scouring the waiver wire for a plug-in play. Drew Brees, Jay Cutler, Aaron Rodgers, and Philip Rivers–four of the top 10 quarterbacks drafted this year–all get the week off.



